EAP WG Status Web Page

Last Updated: November 1, 2007

This page contains information on the IETF EAP WG, including current status of EAP WG drafts and the list of open and resolved issues.

About the IETF EAP WG

EAP WG charter
EAP Mailing List Archives

Previous Meetings

Minutes and Presentations from IETF 65

Guidance for AAA Key Management

RFC 4962

Document Status

Proposed Standard

RFC3748 (the document formerly known as RFC 2284bis)

Informational RFCs

RFC3579 (RADIUS/EAP, formerly known as RFC 2869bis)
RFC4017 (WLAN Authentication Requirements)
RFC4137 (EAP State Machine)
RFC4186 (EAP SIM)
RFC4187 (EAP AKA)
RFC4284 (EAP Identity Selection)
RFC4746 (EAP PAX)
RFC4763 (EAP SAKE)
RFC4764 (EAP PSK)
RFC 4793 (EAP POTP)

Completed IETF Last Call

EAP Key Management Framework  IETF Last Call Announcement

In IETF Last Call

Network Selection Problem Statement

EAP Type Code Allocation

Expert Review Template

Reviews

   
EAP Method Reviewer Review Status Disposition
RFC4186    (EAP SIM) Bernard Aboba Review Submitted Approved Published
RFC4187     (EAP AKA) Yoshi Ohba Review Submitted Approved Published
RFC4746    (EAP PAX)  Jari Arkko Review Submitted Approved Published
RFC 4763   (EAP SAKE) Jari Arkko Review Submitted Approved Published
RFC4764 (EAP PSK) Jesse Walker Review Submitted Approved Published
RFC 4793 (EAP POTP) Jari Arkko Review Submitted Approved Published
EAP-IKEv2 Pasi Eronen Pre-Review Submitted Denied Revision Needed
EAP Double TLS Hannes Tschofenig Review Submitted Denied Revision Needed
EAP Smartcard Type Glen Zorn Review Submitted Denied Revision Needed
EAP MAKE   EAP-MAKE Bernard Aboba Review Submitted Denied Protocol renamed

Abandoned Work

Compound Binding Problem Draft
Security Analysis of Key Distribution
EAP Key Management Extensions

Lower Layer Review

Lower Layer Review Template

IEEE 802 Standards utilizing EAP

IEEE 802 archive access (granted to EAP WG participants, ask chairs for password):

IEEE 802.1X-2004
IEEE 802.11i-2004
IEEE 802.16e-2005
Review of IEEE 802.16e D8
Review of IEEE 802.16eD10

IEEE 802 Drafts utilizing EAP

IEEE 802.11rD5.0
IEEE 802.1af

IETF/IEEE 802 Liaison Status

IETF/IEEE 802 Liaison web page

IPR Declarations

Network Selection
EAP/IKEv2
EAP/802.1X

Open Issues List

A description in red implies that no issue has been submitted (if you are the owner of such a message, please send EAP WG an issue). An asterix following an Issue number (e.g. Issue#666*) means that the issue entry is incomplete, and the author is expected to send additional text to EAP WG .

To submit a new issue, send an e-mail to the EAP WG Mailing List, using the following template:

Description of issue
Submitter name: Your_Name_Here
Submitter email address: Your_Email_Address_Here
Date first submitted: Insert_Date_Here
Reference: URL to e-mail describing problem, if available
Document: Document Requiring change [RFC2284bis, RFC 2869bis, Keying Framework, EAP Binding, State Machine]
Comment type: ['T'echnical | 'E'ditorial]
Priority: ['S' Must fix | '1' Should fix | '2' May fix ]
Section: Insert_Section_Number_Here
Rationale/Explanation of issue:
Length description of problem

Requested change:
Proposed changes to the document. Please be specific about what text you want to change, add or delete. Issues cannot be considered until specific text is provided.

For open issues, the following values are used in the Status Field:

Text Proposed - Text has been proposed on the list, and noconsensus has been reached
Accepted - Text has been proposed, consensus has been reached, butthe fix hasn't been included in a specification yet.
Pending - Discussion is on-going, no proposed text has been proposed
No Discussion - No discussion has been initiated on this issue.
Clarifying Text Required - The issue can be closed if additional clarifying text is added to the draft
Possible Reject - Issue will be rejected unless objections occur.

WG Work Items

   
EAP Keying Framework

Issue Number

Status Type Description Owner
Issue 398 Pending Technical Discuss Sam Hartman
Issue 404 KEYING-20 Technical Peer-Id & Server-Id in Tunneled Methods Paul Funk
Issue 411 Pending Technical Relationship to RFC 4962 Charlie Kaufman

 

Network Selection Problem Statement

Issue Number

Status Type Description Owner
Issue 413 Pending Technical Credential Selection Tim Polk

Work Reviewed by EAP WG

RFC3579

Issue Number

Status Type Description Owner
Issue 242 RFC3579 Technical Errata Jari Arkko

 

EAP IKEv2

Issue Number

Status Type Description Owner
Issue 304 No Discussion Technical Review of EAP IKEv2 Pasi Eronen

Abandoned Work

Compound Binding

Issue Number

Status Type Description Owner
Issue 191 No Discussion Editorial Editorial Review of Binding-04 Jari Arkko
Issue 192 No Discussion Technical Technical Review of Binding-04 Jari Arkko

Resolved Issues List

The following table contains the issues that have already been resolved,and the fix included in a revision of the specifications.

 
Issue Number Fixed in Type Description Owner
Issue 1 RFC 2284bis-03 Technical EAP NAK allows only one alternative method David Reeder
Issue 2 RFC2284bis-08 Technical "Alternative Indications" not well defined Bernard Aboba
Issue 3 SM-02 Technical EAP needs a state machine Bryan Payne
Issue 4 RFC2284bis-05 Technical EAP multiplexing model not described Bernard Aboba
Issue 5 RFC2284bis-03 Editorial Editorial changes to section 4.2 Bernard Aboba
Issue 6 RFC 2284bis-02 Technical No IANA considerations section Bernard Aboba
Issue 7 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Ability to authenticate with multiple methods one after another not specified Bernard Aboba
Issue 8 RFC 2284bis-02 Technical Support for Vendor-Specific types Bernard Aboba
Issue 9 RFC 2284bis-02 Technical Support for Method Type Expansion Bernard Aboba
Issue 10 EAP-06 Technical No support for acknowledged Success or Failure Simon Blake-Wilson
Issue 11 RFC2284bis-04 Technical No threat model Bernard Aboba
Issue 12 RFC2284bis-04 Technical No support for localization Bernard Aboba
Issue 13 RFC 2284bis-08 Technical Identifier usage not specified Bernard Aboba
Issue 14 RFC 2284bis-08 Technical EAP transport behavior not specified Bernard Aboba
Issue 15 KEYING-02 Technical NASREQ Key Distribution insecure Jesse Walker
Issue 16 RFC2869bis-02 Technical EAP corner conditions Bernard Aboba
Issue 17 Reject Technical EAP Negotiation Method Caron
Issue 18 RFC 2284bis-08 Technical Identifier behavior details Bernard Aboba
Issue 19 RFC2869bis-02 Technical User-Name in EAP/RADIUS Tom Bonacci
Issue 20 RFC2869bis-02 Technical Reply-Message attribute in Access-Accept or Access-Reject Bernard Aboba
Issue 21 RFC2284bis-05 Editorial Editorial issues with RFC 2284bis-04 Jesse Walker
Issue 22 RFC2284bis-05 Technical Issues with mandatory to implement method Jesse Walker
Issue 23 Reject Technical Contents of Identity Request Payload Jesse Walker
Issue 24 RFC2284bis-05 Technical EAP and Ciphersuite Negotiation Jesse Walker
Issue 25 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Spoofing and Duplicate detection Jesse Walker
Issue 26 EAP-06 Technical Unprotected Success and Failure Jesse Walker
Issue 27 RFC2284bis-05 Technical Peer timeout and retry Jesse Walker
Issue 28 RFC2284bis-05 Technical Per-Packet Integrity Protection Jesse Walker
Issue 29 RFC2284bis-05 Technical Security Considerations Jesse Walker
Issue 30 RFC2284bis-05 Technical Negotiation Attacks Jesse Walker
Issue 31 RFC2284bis-05 Technical PEP and PDP separation Jesse Walker
Issue 32 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Keying confirmation Jesse Walker
Issue 33 Reject Technical Encoding of Identity Response Mark Wodrich
Issue 34 RFC 2284bis-07 Technical Notification Usage Bernard Aboba
Issue 35 Reject Technical NAK'ing an Identity Request John Vollbrecht
Issue 36 RFC 2284bis-07 Technical When may a NAK be sent? Bernard Aboba
Issue 37 RFC2284bis-08 Technical EAP stack representation Bernard Aboba
Issue 38 Reject Technical Language negotiation Bernard Aboba
Issue 39 RFC 2284bis-07 Technical When can an Identity Request be sent? Bernard Aboba
Issue 40 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Man-in-the-middle attacks on EAP method sequences and tunnels Bernard Aboba
Issue 41 EAP-01 Technical Nak of extended type Bernard Aboba
Issue 42 Reject Technical EAP Enhancements Tena Tsou
Issue 43 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Security Claims Bernard Aboba
Issue 44 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Peer-to-Peer Operation of EAP Bernard Aboba
Issue 45 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Addition of OTP and GTC Methods Bernard Aboba
Issue 46 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Pass through clarification Bernard Aboba
Issue 47 KEYING-00 Technical Keying requirements not specified Bernard Aboba
Issue 48 RFC2869bis-05 Technical Role Reversal Not Supported Bernard Aboba
Issue 49 RFC2284bis-10 Technical Spoofing of EAP Success/Failure Bernard Aboba
Issue 50 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Media requirements Bernard Aboba
Issue 51 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Turnaround requirements James Carlson
Issue 52 EAP-01 Technical Identity requery James Carlson
Issue 53 RFC2284bis-09 Technical NAK of Identity message James Carlson
Issue 54 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Problem with NAK type James Carlson
Issue 55 RFC2284bis-09 Editorial Header issues James Carlson
Issue 56 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Expanded Type Format Paul Funk
Issue 57 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Bi-directional vs. Mutual Authentication Jesse Walker
Issue 58 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Miscellaneous -08 NITs Jesse Walker
Issue 59 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Failed Authentication and EAP Failure Nick Petroni
Issue 60 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Ordering guarantees Bernard Aboba
Issue 61 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Support for EAP Sequences Hao Zhou
Issue 62 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Protected success/failure Jesse Walker
Issue 63 Reject Technical Identifier space advice Bernard Aboba
Issue 64 Binding-04 Technical Problem statement issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 65 Binding-04 Technical Downgrade attacks Dan Simon
Issue 66 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Mandatory for who? Bernard Aboba
Issue 67 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Lower layer security requirement Bernard Aboba
Issue 68 RFC2284bis-09 Technical MIC coverage Bernard Aboba
Issue 69 RFC2284bis-09 Technical Inconsistent language in introduction/abstract Nick Petroni
Issue 70 Binding-04 Technical Which PRF? Bernard Aboba
Issue 71 KEYING-06 Technical Key framework review Jari Arkko
Issue 72 RFC2869bis-08 Technical RFC 2896bis review Jari Arkko
Issue 73 EAP-01 Technical Various RFC 2284bis Comments Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 74 EAP-02 Technical Concern on invalid MIC Yoshihiro Ohba
Issue 75 EAP-01 Editorial Terminology wording John Vollbrecht
Issue 76 Reject Technical Multiple methods in a sequence John Vollbrecht
Issue 77 EAP-00 Technical Section 7.2 security claim [f] excessive Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 78 Reject Technical More terminology John Vollbrecht
Issue 79 EAP-01 Technical Key Strength Estimate Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 80 EAP-02 Technical Success Indications Nick Petroni
Issue 81 Reject Technical Auditable Events John Vollbrecht
Issue 82 EAP-01 Technical Response handling Bernard Aboba
Issue 83 RFC2869bis-13 Technical Invalid packet handling Bernard Aboba
Issue 84 RFC2869bis-10 Technical Miscellaneous Nits Steve Bellovin
Issue 85 RFC2869bis-10 Editorial Minor editorial comments Pasi Eronen
Issue 86 EAP-01 Technical Separation of EAP server and authenticator Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 87 Reject Technical Handling of EAP Type Change James Carlson
Issue 88 Binding-04 Technical Review of Binding-01 Jukka Ylitalo
Issue 89 Binding-04 Technical Comments on Binding-01 Jari Arkko
Issue 90 Reject Technical Simplify Introduction John Vollbrecht
Issue 91 EAP-02 Editorial Definitions John Vollbrecht
Issue 92 EAP-02 Technical Integrity Protection John Vollbrecht
Issue 93 Reject Editorial Simplify Description John Vollbrecht
Issue 94 EAP-02 Technical Is EAP a lock-step protocol? Pasi Eronen
Issue 95 Reject Technical Sequences John Vollbrecht
Issue 96 EAP-02 Technical Notification Clarification Yoshihiro Obha
Issue 97 EAP-02 Technical Strict interpretation Bernard Aboba
Issue 98 SM-00 Technical State machine issues Jari Arkko
Issue 99 Reject Technical Double Expansion Bernard Aboba
Issue 100 RFC2869bis-11 Technical User-Name in Access-Challenge or Access-Reject Jo Hermans
Issue 101 RFC2869bis-12 Technical EAP Identifier Conflict Pasi Eronen
Issue 102 RFC2869bis-13 Technical Fragmentation: RADIUS obligation to MTU Tom Bonacci
Issue 103 RFC2869bis-14 Technical Timeouts Pasi Eronen
Issue 104 EAP-03 Technical Sequence Prohibition Bernard Aboba
Issue 105 EAP-03 Technical Multiplexing clarification Bernard Aboba
Issue 106 EAP-03 Editorial No Changes Appendix Henrik Lefkowetz
Issue 107 EAP-03 Technical Missing definition of Experimental Type Henrik Lefkowetz
Issue 108 EAP-03 Technical Downgrade Attacks on Lower Layer Ciphersuite Negotiations Benoit de Boursetty
Issue 109 EAP-03 Editorial Attacker or Adversary? Benoit de Boursetty
Issue 110 EAP-03 Editorial Miscellaneous Nits Bernard Aboba
Issue 111 EAP-03 Technical Lower Layer Requirements Bernard Aboba
Issue 112 EAP-03 Technical Rewrite of IANA considerations Bernard Aboba
Issue 113 EAP-03 Technical Rewrite of Security Considerations Section Bernard Aboba
Issue 114 EAP-03 Technical Terminology fixes Bernard Aboba
Issue 115 EAP-03 Technical Multiplexing fixes Bernard Aboba
Issue 116 EAP-03 Technical Success and Failure cleanup Bernard Aboba
Issue 117 EAP-03 Technical Miscellaneous technical nits Bernard Aboba
Issue 118 Reject Technical Mutual authentication Dror Caspi
Issue 119 EAP-05 Technical EAP inappropriate for use with peer-to-peer Jesse Walker
Issue 120 EAP-03 Technical Passphrases in EAP Lauri Tarkkala
Issue 121 EAP-04 Technical Document meaning of successful authentication Pasi Eronen
Issue 122 EAP-03 Technical Clarification of LL requirements Mohan Parthasarathy
Issue 123 Binding-04 Technical Non KEYING-generating methods and binding Jari Arkko
Issue 124 EAP-03 Technical Identity Protection Mark Schurman
Issue 125 Rejected Technical Retransmission Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 126 EAP-03 Editorial Miscellaneous NITs Jari Arkko
Issue 127 EAP-03 Editorial Security Terms Jari Arkko
Issue 128 EAP-03 Editorial Encapsulation Reference Jari Arkko
Issue 129 EAP-03 Technical More NITs Jari Arkko
Issue 130 Reject Technical Potential Deadlock Lauri Tarkkala
Issue 131 EAP-04 Technical Lower layer success indications Pasi Eronen
Issue 132 EAP-03 Technical Redundancy of Section 7.14 Pasi Eronen
Issue 133 RFC2869bis-22 Technical IESG Comments on RFC 2869bis Russ Housley
Issue 134 EAP-04 Technical EAP Transport Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 135 Reject Technical SSID in PRF Bob Moskowitz
Issue 136 SM-00 Technical SM-02 NITs Jari Arkko
Issue 137 SM-00 Technical Authenticator Timeout Failure Issue Jari Arkko
Issue 138 EAP-04 Technical Miscellaneous -03 Issues Jari Arkko
Issue 139 EAP-04 Technical Response to Duplicate Requests Nick Petroni
Issue 140 SM-00 Technical SM Incompatibilities with RFC 2284bis Jari Arkko
Issue 141 EAP-04 Technical Minor NITs Pasi Eronen
Issue 142 EAP-04 Technical Contents of EAP-Request Identity Tim Moore
Issue 143 EAP-05 Editorial EAP-04 Editorial Nits Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 144 EAP-05 Technical Use of Zero in a Nak Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 145 Reject (duplicate) Technical Terminology: Man-in-the-Middle Resistance Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 146 EAP-05 Technical Multiplexing Model Requirements Henrik Levkowetz
Issue 147 EAP-05 Technical Initial Key Activation John Vollbrecht
Issue 148 EAP-05 Technical Sequences John Vollbrecht
Issue 149 Reject Technical Peer Policy John Vollbrecht
Issue 150 EAP-05 Technical Lower Layer Behavior for Limited Access Yoshihiro Ohba
Issue 151 EAP-05 Technical EAP-04 Comments Pasi Eronen
Issue 152 EAP-05 Technical Lower layer indications Pasi Eronen
Issue 153 EAP-05 Technical EAP OTP Replay Protection Joe Salowey
Issue 154 EAP-05 Technical Identity Response Mismatch Joe Salowey
Issue 155 SM-00 Technical EAP SM-03 Review Jari Arkko
Issue 156 EAP-05 Technical Terminology reorganization Bernard Aboba
Issue 157 RFC2869bis-23 Technical Order of Attribute Processing Bernard Aboba
Issue 158 EAP-05 Editorial Miscellaneous Nits Bernard Aboba
Issue 159 EAP-05 Editorial Organization Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 160 Reject Technical Network Selection Assistance Farid Adrangi
Issue 161 SM-01, RFC 2284bis-07 Technical State Machine Demultiplexing Florent Bersani
Issue 162 EAP-05 Technical Minimum MTU Not Defined Lauri Tarkkala
Issue 163 EAP-05 Editorial Minor Editorial Nit Lauri Tarkkala
Issue 164 EAP-05 Technical Conflicting Implementation Note Joe Salowey
Issue 165 EAP-05 Technical Applicability Statement Bernard Aboba
Issue 166 Reject Technical Message Authenticator String Needs Clarification Brian Burch
Issue 167 EAP-05 Technical Cleartext Passwords in EAP Bernard Aboba
Issue 168 Reject Technical Peer Link Usage Bernard Aboba
Issue 169 KEYING-00 Technical Review of Key Framework-07 Dan Simon
Issue 170 EAP-06 Technical Terminology Bernard Aboba
Issue 171 EAP-06 Technical IKEv2 over TCP Bernard Aboba
Issue 172 EAP-06 Editorial Miscellaneous NITs Bernard Aboba
Issue 173 EAP-06 Editorial RFC 2284bis Method Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 174 Rejected Technical Mandatory to Implement Dorothy Stanley
Issue 175 EAP-06 Technical Rewrite of Section 7.13 Bernard Aboba
Issue 176 EAP-06 Technical Sync on key framework reqts Bernard Aboba
Issue 177 KEYING-00 Technical Rewrite of SA Sections Bernard Aboba
Issue 178 KEYING-00 Technical Review of Key Framework Document Hannes Tschofenig
Issue 179 Reject Technical EAP PRF Uri Blumenthal
Issue 180 KEYING-02 Technical Conversation Overview Pasi Eronen
Issue 181 KEYING-00 Editorial Key NITs Bernard Aboba
Issue 182 KEYING-00 Technical Authorization Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 183 KEYING-01 Technical Security Associations Pasi Eronen
Issue 184 KEYING-01 Editorial Typos/Grammar Issues Nick Petroni
Issue 185 KEYING-02 Technical Key Framework Review Russ Housley
Issue 186 RFC2284bis-07 Editorial Miscellaneous NITs Bernard Aboba
Issue 187 KEYING-02 Technical Service SAs Pasi Eronen
Issue 188 RFC2284bis-07 Technical Packet ordering Margaret Waserman
Issue 189 RFC2284bis-07 Technical Handling of the Identity Response Joe Salowey
Issue 190 RFC2284bis-07 Editorial Inconsistent Capitalization Bernard Aboba
Issue 193 SM-02 Technical Peer SM Review Bernard Aboba
Issue 194 SM-02 Technical Standalone Authenticator SM Review Bernard Aboba
Issue 195 SM-02 Technical Backend Authenticator SM Review Bernard Aboba
Issue 196 SM-02 Technical Peer SM Issues Ashwin Palekar
Issue 197 SM-02 Technical EAP SM Review Michael Richardson
Issue 198 SM-02 Technical Other EAP Peer SM Issues Ashwin Palekar
Issue 199 Reject Technical Full Authenticator SM Issue Ashwin Palekar
Issue 200 RFC2284bis-07 Technical Endpoint verification Bernard Aboba
Issue 201 RFC2284bis-07 Editorial Some NITs Jose Puthenkulam
Issue 202 RFC2284bis-07 Editorial Peer-to-Peer Cleanup Bernard Aboba
Issue 203 SM-02 Technical Peer SM Comments Joe Salowey
Issue 204 Reject Technical Peer-to-Peer operation Bernard Aboba
Issue 205 RFC2284bis-07 Technical Peer-to-peer operation Bernard Aboba
Issue 206 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Identity Request Nagi_Reddy.Jonnala
Issue 207 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Miscellaneous Comments Russ Housley
Issue 208 RFC2284bis-08 Editorial Physical Security Steve Bellovin
Issue 209 RFC2284bis-08 Editorial Applicability Statement Allison Mankin
Issue 210 KEYING-02 Editorial No name for the "top EAP keying material" Florent Bersani
Issue 211 RFC2284bis-08 Editorial Fast Reconnect Florent Bersani
Issue 212 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Protected Result Indications Russ Housley
Issue 213 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Cleanup issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 214 KEYING-02 Technical Appendix E vs. EMSK Guidelines Jari Arkko
Issue 215 KEYING-03 Technical Comments on Section 3 of Key Framework Joe Salowey
Issue 216 KEYING-02 Technical MSK Issues Jari Arkko
Issue 217 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Result Indications Bernard Aboba
Issue 218 RFC2284bis-08 Technical TLS Example Bernard Aboba
Issue 219 Reject Technical Session Independence Hannes Tschofenig
Issue 220 KEYING-02 Technical Relationship between AAA-Key & MSK/EMSK Hannes Tschofenig
Issue 221 KEYING-03 Technical EMSK Usage Guidelines Joe Salowey
Issue 222 RFC2284bis-08 Technical Synchronized State Joe Salowey
Issue 223 RFC2284bis-09 Editorial PRI Cleanup Bernard Aboba
Issue 224 REQ-01 Technical State Synchronization Joe Salowey
Issue 225 REQ-01 Technical Review Steve Bellovin
Issue 226 REQ-01 Technical Comments on WLAN requirements Bernard Aboba
Issue 227 REQ-01 Technical Corrections Russ Housley
Issue 228 RFC2284bis-10 Editorial Typos for Auth48 Bernard Aboba
Issue 229 SM-03 Technical EAP Peer SM Review Bernard Aboba
Issue 230 SM-03 Editorial EAP SM NITs Jari Arkko
Issue 231 RFC2284bis-10 Editorial RFC 3748 NITs Florent Bersani
Issue 232 REQ-01 Technical User Identity Confidentiality Florent Bersani
Issue 233 REQ-01 Technical WLAN Comments Avi Lior
Issue 234 REQ-01 Technical Comments Pasi Eronen
Issue 235 KEYING-02 Technical Rewrite of Section 1 Bernard Aboba
Issue 236 KEYING-02 Technical Rewrite of Section 2 Bernard Aboba
Issue 237 KEYING-02 Technical Reference Cleanup Bernard Aboba
Issue 238 KEYING-02 Editorial AAA-Key Missing From Figure 5 Jari Arkko
Issue 239 KEYING-02 Editorial Various NITs Jari Arkko
Issue 240 KEYING-02 Editorial Reference Issues Jari Arkko
Issue 241 Reject Technical Corner case in 802.1X/EAP State Machines Bernard Aboba
Issue 243 REQ-03 Technical Clarification of "State Synchronization" Jari Arkko
Issue 244 RFC 3748 Editorial Fixes for Type Code Allocations Jari Arkko
Issue 245 RFC 3748 Technical EAP Restart Issue John Vollbrecht
Issue 246 RFC 3748 Editorial IANA Considerations Florent Bersani
Issue 247 SM-04 Editorial Comments on EAP SM (Editorial) Florent Bersani
Issue 248 SM-04 Technical Comments on EAP SM (Technical) Florent Bersani
Issue 249 Reject Editorial General comments on EAP SM Florent Bersani
Issue 250 SM-04 Editorial Definition Florent Bersani
Issue 251 SM-04 Technical Identity Attacks Florent Bersani
Issue 252 Reject Technical CurrentId Issue Suresh Babu
Issue 253 Reject Editorial AAA-Key Name is Misleading Joe Salowey
Issue 254 KEYING-05 Technical Key Lifetime Issues Bernard Aboba
Issue 255 REQ-04 Technical IESG DISCUSS comments on authorization Allison Mankin
Issue 256 IDSEL-04 Editorial Miscellaneous NITs Bernard Aboba
Issue 257 KEYING-04 Editorial Editorial Comments on Keying Framework Florent Bersani
Issue 258 KEYING-04 Editorial Discovery Florent Bersani
Issue 259 KEYING-04 Technical Null Transforms Florent Bersani
Issue 260 Reject Technical Size of MSK and EMSK Florent Bersani
Issue 261 Reject (duplicate of 278) Technical TEK Lifetime Florent Bersani
Issue 262 KEYING-04 Technical MSK Naming Florent Bersani
Issue 263 Reject Technical EAP AKA Florent Bersani
Issue 264 Reject Technical Domino Effect Florent Bersani
Issue 265 KEYING-04 Technical EMSK Transport Florent Bersani
Issue 266 Reject (Duplicate of 275) Technical Appendix Incoherence Florent Bersani
Issue 267 KEYING-04 Technical PRF Negotiation Florent Bersani
Issue 268 Rejected Editorial SM-05 Review Michael Richardson
Issue 269 IDSEL-04 Technical Identity Selection Issue Jari Arkko
Issue 270 KEYING-04 Editorial Informational or Standards Track? Florent Bersani
Issue 271 IDSEL-04 Technical IEEE 802.11 Comments on Identity Selection Stuart Kerry
Issue 272 KEYING-04 Editorial Capitalization of Key Words Florent Bersani
Issue 273 KEYING-04 Editorial PMK Naming Florent Bersani
Issue 274 KEYING-04 Editorial Naming of AMSKs Florent Bersani
Issue 275 KEYING-04 Technical AAA-Key Should be Derived from AMSK Joe Salowey
Issue 276 Reject (duplicate of 275) Technical Make Existing vs. Handoff Usage Clearer Jari Arkko
Issue 277 KEYING-06 Editorial Organization of Keying Draft(s) Joe Salowey
Issue 278 KEYING-04 Technical Lifetimes of Keys Internal to EAP Method Jari Arkko
Issue 279 KEYING-08 Technical Keying protocol requirements Jesse Walker
Issue 280 IDSEL-07 Editorial NITs on Identity Selection-05 Bernard Aboba
Issue 281 IDSEL-07 Technical Backward compatibility issue Bernard Aboba